Hilary Clinton actually won the popular vote, with. There are three major flaws, or defects, in the electoral college system. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Choose from 164 different sets of 3 flaws of Electoral college flashcards on Quizlet. We can also break this down another way when it comes to the large states (since all of the 13 smallest states only have a one electoral vote difference between any of them), and look at the 13 largest states represent 295 electoral votes combined, meaning that since only 270 are required to win, theoretically, you only need to focus on the 13 largest states and you can win. Once in a while, though, people do notice and do care — a lot.

But due to the magic of the Electoral College, Donald Trump will … This change in the other states, though, was for partisan reasons as well, not some altruistic methodology that saw importance in the people actually having a true say in the outcome. Every candidate has dozens of national reporters and TV personalities following them to every single stop and we all know what is said each time if you are not living in a bubble. You can change your choices at any time by visiting Your Privacy Controls. In fact, the closest thing to reality that I see people suggesting today is that it was a means to insure that less populous states maintained a say in the Presidency. Extremes can most certainly lead to a super majority taking advantage of a minority. Just admit that you want to either keep the system as is or scrap it so that your party has an electoral advantage over the “enemy”, and we can stop seeing random posts and memes that are mostly nonsensical. In 2016, those 295 electoral votes were split between the parties (as they usually are) with 143 going to Clinton and 152 going to Trump. Now, if your position is simply partisan, meaning you are currently a Democrat that wants to see it abolished because statistically speaking, there seems to be more Democratic voters in the country than Republican voters, or you are a Republican and you love the fact that in the past 19 years, we have had two Republican presidents elected while losing the national popular vote, I get it, but you need to simply admit those are your motives, and stop trying to justify your position with a bunch of made up crap either for or against the Electoral College. Although it is imaginable that a candidate could receive 60% in the 20 most populous states, a candidate will most likely never receive 0% in 30 states. Written By: Arnie J Olsen. Secondly, according to the Constitution, every state gets at least one Representative, no matter their size. I will respond to it more fully later, but initially I would just like to say that I view it as both a gift and an open invitation to others interested in meaningful discourse. they each get one vote; vote on behalf of the people fo…, minimum amount of votes to win with majority, group of electors that elects President and Vice President, person that is part of electoral college that votes for Vice P…, The majority of electors needed to win the presidency, The total number of electors in a presidential election, Members of the House of Reps + Senators in your state =, the part of government that chooses the Vice President if a ti…, the part of government that chooses the President if a tie occ…, is plagued by three major defects: (1) the winner of the popul…, There is the ever-present threat that the winner of the popula…, is the way the electoral votes are distributed among the State…, The popular vote winner has, in fact, failed to win the presid…, 538 (100 senators + 438 reps. from Congress), MOSTLY based on population, based on where people live, and sm…, ALL a states EC votes go to the candidate who wins the majorit…, system used to elect our President and Vice President, bicameral, made up of both the House of Representatives and th…, 435 members, members are assigned to each state based off of p…, 100 members, based off of equal representation. That had nothing to do with the original concept. Anyway, I just wanted to know you had something to do with that, so thank you. The Constitutional Convention established the Electoral College system in 1787. | Open Dialogue What do I say on FlipGrid for my assignment? In the 2016 election, there were around 130 million votes that went to the two leading Candidates. What that means is that a citizen of Wyoming has nearly 4 times the impact of a citizen of Texas when it comes to choosing the next President. Each state is designated a certain number of electors based on how many members they each hold in The House and Senate. There are many critiques that have been made about the controversial system. Prior to that time, the state legislature of most states chose the electors for their state, and those electors were the ones to cast their votes for the Presidency with no input from the people of the state. If we used the Electoral College, and it was based on the number of “electors” allocated to state which was subsequently based on the number of Congressional representatives allocated to the state, land owning white men of slave states could maintain their influence in the outcome of the election. Why does Illinois need so many more people per electoral vote? Grant Preves is a sophomore and is on news team for his first year. As opposed to the House, the amount of representatives each state receives in the Senate isn’t based off population. All state have…, The number of people who voted for a candidate is called the _…, The Electoral College is a system for electing the ___________…, When people vote on election day they are actually voting for…, Whoever gets the most of those votes for the states gets _____…, -majority of delegates at national convention... -run in the 50 s…, closed primaries... ---forcing the candidates to be more polarized, -number of senators and the number of house representatives ... -…, cant trust average citizens to make a wise choice, the votes cast by citizens in an election, votes cast by electors in the electoral college, a group of people representing the states of the US, who forma…, a candidate who is thought to be in the lead, a person chosen by a political party to be a candidate, Add the electoral votes for the Federalists:... CT Federalist (9)…, Add the electoral votes for the Democratic-Republicans: ... GA De….

The problem, though, is it is factually inaccurate. The issue of “bare majority” can also be illustrated in a more realistic example. In Wyoming, there are. Get big dark money, corporate money and billionaire money OUT of elections. I think it is safe to say that the primary reason for the outcry now is simply the divisiveness of the current President, but more interesting in my mind is the absolute lack of knowledge when it comes to the original purpose and intent of the Electoral College, as well as the wide ranging views on why it is either essential to our democracy or the biggest detriment to it that one can imagine. Although this law is clearly needed, it creates further imbalance when election day comes. Everybody’s vote in a country should be worth the same amount.

In that election, the. Instead, the President is elected by 538 electors. By fail-safe, I mean the scene we watched unfold during the Republican national convention when Trump faced a very real possibility of winning the primary battle and yet, not being given the party nomination because there was a considerable movement among electors that did not like the outcome of the primaries to go rogue and choose someone else. Depending on the state, there are a different amount of citizens per representative. This means that Clinton or Trump could have received 60% support in the 20 most populous states, and 0% support in the other 30 states, and could have still won the popular vote. Now, if you do not live in a swing state, that may be a positive because you aren’t hammered constantly by a barrage of televised propaganda and lies like the rest of us, but it does show the disparity caused by the Electoral College. However, arguably the most notable and talked about, is the weight of one’s single vote. Add more polling places so people have an easier time getting to them, especially those that don’t drive, or rely on public transportation. , and one House Representative. | Participation In the 2016 election, Hilary won the popular vote with just under 66 million votes. Back at the time of our founding, you need to recall that different states had very very different laws and interests from one another. And, finally, there was the notion of having “electors” select the President, which is essentially what we ended up with.

With the existence of 24 hour news channels that broadcast nearly every campaign appearance live and nationwide, the impact of actual presence in different locations has been minimized to its lowest levels in our history. There are three major flaws, or defects, in the electoral college system. This site is using cookies under cookie policy. | Liberty This scenario will likely never happen, because it requires candidates to have nearly 100% in 10 states. Covey’s first step was “seek first to understand” and clearly that is your goal. In the least populous state, Wyoming, each one of their three electoral votes represents 191,240 citizens.

This scenario means that you had more votes in total but are still losing the election 10-11. Well, we will never really know if we do not get more people voting, and knowing that EVERY vote counts no matter where you live would seem to be the greatest incentive possible for voters to take the time to do it. Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. 3 major defects of Electoral College. To do anything else, when other states were doing that, would reduce their influence. Tap card to see definition . 40% out of total 20=8 electoral votes). He has enjoyed being a co-host for The Howl and having political debates with fellow... Wolf Prints hopes to foster healthy, thought-provoking discussion. electors chosen same way as members of congress (2 chosen at large) and cast electoral vote in line with statewide popular vote result. With over 300 million citizens, it is impossible to perfectly emulate the population of a country from state to state, with one representative body. …. People that live in the most populous states are harmed, not the other way around, because their votes simply do not carry the same weight as votes cast in small states. In other words, the chances of other states being added to the list of 12 current swing states is remote, and at best, it might jump to 16 swing states. I just read your three pillars piece. Remember, women did not have a vote at this time, and neither did the poor because most states required a man to be a landowner to have a vote. We need elections to be more free and fair, with a better educated voting population that actually turns out to vote. Therefore Illinois is given 20 electoral votes. The Electoral College’s small-state bias had essentially nothing to do with Donald J. Trump’s victory. This will greatly reduce the cost of campaigns, hold the interest of the voters, and allow for candidates to more efficiently spend their time within each region, meeting more voters and paying attention to every corner of the country. Quizlet will be unavailable from 4-5 PM PT. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Like many things in our country, the Electoral College has always been, and will always be, another mechanism for people in power holding onto that power. Wow! On the other hand, if we were determining the outcome of the election based on the popular vote, you can rest assured that both candidates will fight for every vote, regardless of whether it is a red or blue state. …, il your number is called out at the deli to order